Author Topic: Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review  (Read 2277 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline dalethorn

  • Banhammered!
  • Posts: 1241
    • DaleThorn.com
Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review
« on: April 09, 2011, 09:16:33 AM »
I compared the DTX-300p mainly to the Sennheiser PX-200-II, which is a similar design ("closed back"), albeit the DTX-300p is about 2/3 the price of the PX-200-II on average. The DTX-300p is constructed in a very lightweight manner, and didn't look nearly as well made or durable as the PX-200-II at first glance, but that's just an initial impression and since these are both lightweight portable headphones with thin cords, the DTX-300p may hold its own in that area.

The DTX-300p has a 90-degree angled stereo miniplug whereas the PX-200-II has a straight plug. In spite of the angled plug on the DTX-300p, there is a 5 mm plastic extension ahead of the metal/electronic end so that it will fit into recessed minijacks on music players, etc. At first I couldn't get the cushions to fit properly on my ears like the PX-200-II's cushions do, but after a bit of bending and wearing the headband forward on my head to angle the earcups forward, I did manage to get a good fit. Getting a secure fit is essential to providing proper bass response.

Bass with the DTX-300p is similar to the PX-200-II, which is lighter than average for headphones priced between the DTX-300p and PX-200-II. People who like "full strength" bass might prefer something like the Sennheiser PX-100-II, which has a strong bass that's not excessive or boomy. Still, the DTX-300p's bass has a fair degree of impact in most cases, and the detail is very good.

The midrange of the DTX-300p differs from the PX-200-II in where the emphasis lies. The PX-200-II has a "EHHHHHH" to "EEEEEEE" (in English) coloration sound whereas the DTX-300p has a "AWWWWWW" emphasis/coloration, about an octave or two lower. I haven't found either one to be a problem in listening to most music, but your experience could vary depending on what you're most sensitive to. I did compare the midrange of the DTX-300p to Beyer's old studio headphone, the DT-48E (2011 version), and given that the DTX-300p is much less expensive and sounds good on its own, I'll just skip the rest of that comparison and move on to the next test.

The DTX-300p's highs are smooth, but rolled off about the same as the PX-200-II, which is down about 6 db or so at 12 khz (compared to most higher-priced headphones) when running from an iPod music player. I didn't sense a deficiency in the highs, which balance well with the rest of the frequency range in my listening tests.

My overall conclusion is that the DTX-300p's sound compares favorably to headphones costing nearly twice as much, and whereas some low-to-mid-priced headphones are picky about what type of music sounds best on them, the DTX-300p sounded good with everything I played.

In addition to the pop music tracks listed below, which I used mainly for detecting weaknesses or other problems with the sound, I played a wide variety of genres (Jazz, Diana Krall, Bill Evans Trio; Bach organ, Biggs; Beethoven 9th, Solti CSO; Chopin, Moravec; Reggae, Marley, Tosh; Country, Haggard, Yoakam; Verdi, Domingo; Sinatra and Bennett; Punk, Germs, Fear, Sid Vicious, Playpen; Medieval, Madrigali, Medieval Babes; Trance, Mylene Farmer, etc.)

The following are some of the music tracks I tested with, and the main features I listened for with those tracks:

Blues Project - Caress Me Baby (piercing guitar sound, handled well).
Cocteau Twins - Carolyn's Fingers (guitar string detail and quality, excellent).
Commodores - Night Shift (bass detail, excellent).
Germs - Forming (raw garage sound, good).
Lick The Tins - Can't Help Falling In Love (tin whistle, very clear and clean).
Lou Reed - Walk On The Wild Side (bass impact fair; detail good).
REM - Radio Free Europe (drum impact, good).
Rolling Stones - She's So Cold (bass impact and guitar sound, fair).
U2 - With Or Without You (bass fair to weak; high-pitched instruments/sibilants handled well).
Van Morrison - Into The Mystic (bass, weak).
Who - Bargain (voice trailing off: "best I ever had", good vocal harmonics).


« Last Edit: April 17, 2011, 12:55:01 PM by dalethorn »
"Admit nothing.  Deny everything.  Demand proof, then refuse to accept it" -- CIA manual.

Offline dalethorn

  • Banhammered!
  • Posts: 1241
    • DaleThorn.com
Re: Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review
« Reply #1 on: April 09, 2011, 09:20:02 AM »
Well, it's not the DT-1350 I wanted, but B&H is being evasive about that one.  In this review, I mentioned comparing the mids of the DTX-300p to the Beyer DT-48E, and didn't offer any specifics.  Most people won't know, but some of you may guess what that means.  An enormous difference.  Still, the little $59 USD 'phone (which Headroom sold for $49) isn't bad for portable use.
"Admit nothing.  Deny everything.  Demand proof, then refuse to accept it" -- CIA manual.

Offline Azathoth

  • The Daemon Sultan
  • Global Moderator
  • Posts: 2282
  • defiling the cosmos
    • The Filipino Metal Scene
Re: Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review
« Reply #2 on: April 15, 2011, 04:14:58 AM »
Hmmmm, looks like this budget entry from Beyer is a competent all-arounder, may very well be smaller portable version of my DT 150. Would you describe their midrange as the focus of the overall signature, and is it dry in nature?



efficiut daemones, ut quae non sunt, sic tamen quasi sint, conspicienda hominibus exhibeant

Offline Mochan

  • Gold Saint
  • Posts: 2895
  • Tsup!~ suck suck suck
Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review
« Reply #3 on: April 15, 2011, 04:20:35 AM »
What? where's the DT1350?

Anyway this looks like a worthy opponent for the PX200
Home: Mios, Lelouche, GS Ultra
Portable: Merlin, MS400, ESW9, X10, Hephaes, Popo, RealVoice, Solo HD
Sagittarius 9pm. Don't be late.

Offline dalethorn

  • Banhammered!
  • Posts: 1241
    • DaleThorn.com
Re: Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review
« Reply #4 on: April 15, 2011, 05:33:21 AM »
Hmmmm, looks like this budget entry from Beyer is a competent all-arounder, may very well be smaller portable version of my DT 150. Would you describe their midrange as the focus of the overall signature, and is it dry in nature?
I'd sure say the midrange is the focus, since it's light in the bass and treble.  Definitely dry.  But now I've been listening to the DT-1350 for two days, and the DTX-300p sounds *way* light on the ends.  I still think they sound good on their own, just don't compare them to something weighty or dark like the PX-100-II.
"Admit nothing.  Deny everything.  Demand proof, then refuse to accept it" -- CIA manual.

Offline dalethorn

  • Banhammered!
  • Posts: 1241
    • DaleThorn.com
Re: Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review
« Reply #5 on: April 15, 2011, 05:39:04 AM »
What? where's the DT1350?
Anyway this looks like a worthy opponent for the PX200
You definitely don't wanna compare the DTX-300p to the DT-1350.  But the 300p is comparable to the PX-200-II.  The PX is more shifted toward the bright side around 2-3 khz, like a lot of the Sennheisers, and the 300p shifted more toward the mids around 400 hz or so, like a lot of the Beyers.  The PX is built a lot better and stronger (you won't believe how cheap the 300p looks when you hold it in your hands), but the retail price is a lot more, so if you took real care with the 300p, it might be the better bargain.
"Admit nothing.  Deny everything.  Demand proof, then refuse to accept it" -- CIA manual.

Offline dalethorn

  • Banhammered!
  • Posts: 1241
    • DaleThorn.com
Re: Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review
« Reply #6 on: April 16, 2011, 07:45:20 AM »
Update: I guess the DT-1350 has spoiled me completely, and while I can still listen to the DTX-300p for portable use, I can no longer listen to the Senn PX-200-II.  Just sounds too weird.  Senn should issue a new version of the closed PX-200-II and do what Beyer does - shift that emphasis in the upper midrange back down to the middle, like the DTX-300p.
"Admit nothing.  Deny everything.  Demand proof, then refuse to accept it" -- CIA manual.

Offline Azathoth

  • The Daemon Sultan
  • Global Moderator
  • Posts: 2282
  • defiling the cosmos
    • The Filipino Metal Scene
Re: Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review
« Reply #7 on: April 16, 2011, 09:36:12 PM »
Senn should issue a new version of the closed PX-200-II and do what Beyer does - shift that emphasis in the upper midrange back down to the middle, like the DTX-300p.

Oh nice, now these are candidates for my next portable set. Exactly what I want from my midrange. I guess I should expect that statement you said about the 300p's relative fragility as I've seen that headphone design with some other manufacturers. But for $60 I'll take that trade-off as I take good care of my gear anyway.



efficiut daemones, ut quae non sunt, sic tamen quasi sint, conspicienda hominibus exhibeant

Offline dalethorn

  • Banhammered!
  • Posts: 1241
    • DaleThorn.com
Re: Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review
« Reply #8 on: April 16, 2011, 10:31:33 PM »
Oh nice, now these are candidates for my next portable set. Exactly what I want from my midrange. I guess I should expect that statement you said about the 300p's relative fragility as I've seen that headphone design with some other manufacturers. But for $60 I'll take that trade-off as I take good care of my gear anyway.
My confidence is up, as I just ordered the white color DTX300.  Since my DT-1350 is off to Montana for testing, I'll be using the DTX300 most of the time for the next two weeks.  The red color set I have now is actually a great color.
"Admit nothing.  Deny everything.  Demand proof, then refuse to accept it" -- CIA manual.

Offline marcusd

  • The UWA
  • Admin
  • Posts: 9225
    • Headfonics
Re: Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review
« Reply #9 on: April 16, 2011, 11:00:21 PM »
My confidence is up, as I just ordered the white color DTX300.  Since my DT-1350 is off to Montana for testing, I'll be using the DTX300 most of the time for the next two weeks.  The red color set I have now is actually a great color.

Oh now you are rocking Dale, do submit a nice review to the new site when you have a chance ;) let me sort out your ability to do that ;)
♫♪♫d(^_^)♫♪♫


Offline dalethorn

  • Banhammered!
  • Posts: 1241
    • DaleThorn.com
Re: Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review
« Reply #10 on: April 17, 2011, 08:28:55 AM »
Oh now you are rocking Dale, do submit a nice review to the new site when you have a chance ;) let me sort out your ability to do that ;)
Thinking about that ... start off with a link to the original article on Headphiles, and then get into post-review impressions, such as thoughts about why it sounds like it does?
"Admit nothing.  Deny everything.  Demand proof, then refuse to accept it" -- CIA manual.

Offline dalethorn

  • Banhammered!
  • Posts: 1241
    • DaleThorn.com
Re: Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review
« Reply #11 on: April 22, 2011, 11:42:40 AM »
You might remember where I referred to the DTX-300p as very, er, economically constructed.  The two little "pads" under the headband are already coming off - the glue has more or less liquified and I keep pushing them back into place, but sooner or later I will have to find some appropriate glue that will secure hard rubber to stainless steel.  No other complaints except the cushions slide around on my ears easily, and the positioning is critical.  I was playing a 12 khz tone and shifted the cushion just a millimeter - goodbye tone.
"Admit nothing.  Deny everything.  Demand proof, then refuse to accept it" -- CIA manual.

Offline dalethorn

  • Banhammered!
  • Posts: 1241
    • DaleThorn.com
Re: Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review
« Reply #12 on: May 04, 2011, 09:56:40 AM »
I really like the DTX-300p.  So much, I bought an extra set.  Good thing too, because the first set is broken already.  I might have mentioned these were very - ummm, economically constructed.  Very economical.  The left headpiece just fell off.  If you buy these things, don't wiggle the headpieces too much, and I would recommend against folding them up and unfolding very many times.  Best to just wear around neck and place carefully on ears.  Which is a trick in itself.  Highly recommended, though.
"Admit nothing.  Deny everything.  Demand proof, then refuse to accept it" -- CIA manual.

Offline dumplingboy

  • Roadie
  • Posts: 418
  • 君の知らない物語
Re: Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review
« Reply #13 on: May 04, 2011, 10:07:36 AM »
So your DTX-300p's only lasted for about a month? That is some "economical" build quality by Beyer. Are these made in China instead of Germany?
ex-
ex-

we headphilers are NUTS

Offline dalethorn

  • Banhammered!
  • Posts: 1241
    • DaleThorn.com
Re: Beyerdynamic DTX-300p review
« Reply #14 on: May 04, 2011, 10:20:17 AM »
So your DTX-300p's only lasted for about a month? That is some "economical" build quality by Beyer. Are these made in China instead of Germany?
Made in Germany?  hahahaha - I almost fell off of my chair.  German wage scale, ya know.  Yep, they are made in China all right.  And probably not the better factory in China either.  But that's OK - I'm going to be real careful with the second set, and if I don't break the wire (no strain relief), maybe I can get 2 or 3 months.

I'm going to get a RMA from Beyer or whoever and see if I can get these repaired.  That should be interesting.
"Admit nothing.  Deny everything.  Demand proof, then refuse to accept it" -- CIA manual.

 

anything